The mains steps towards a living Sélune river !
The reopening of the Sélune Valley, a prelude to its re-naturalization, is a long-standing project punctuated by strong legislative, regulatory and judicial decisions:
Classification by order of the Sélune under the free movement of migratory fish. This classification required the establishment of devices on the two dams to ensure the free movement of migratory fish. Studies conducted by EDF and the State services concluded that it was technically impossible to implement such a system.
Clarification by ministerial order of species for which the previous ranking was deemed effective (Atlantic salmon, sea trout, brown trout, European eel, pike, sea lamprey, river lamprey). EDF then had a period of 5 years to comply with its obligations and to meet the standards, without compensation or the possibility of derogation.
Approval of the master plan of development and water management (SDAGE) of the Seine-Normandy basin. This master plan stated, among other things, that the non-renewal of concessions and the removal of the Sélune dams were a condition if free movement of fish cannot be respected.
The European Water Framework Directive (WFD) to preserve and restore aquatic waterbodies and to achieve good status of freshwater by 2027 at the latest. This directive also calls to respect the commitments made in the application of the pre-existing directives, in particular the protection of waterways habitats and aquatic species in the Natura 2000 Framework. In this respect, it is observed that the Mont Saint Michel Bay, whose ecological functionality is highly dependent on the basins that flow into it, is in a special conservation zone.
EDF filed a concession renewal application on December the 17th, 2004 for a period of 40 years. The consultations that followed this request (consultations of services and communities, public inquiry) made it possible to raise the various issues of Sélune and these two dams.
2005 : A clear positioning of the CLE of the SAGE Sélune
The SAGE, pronounced for the removal of the dams in 2013, during the next evacuation.
In fact, very quickly, the SAGE Sélune took a position on the fate of the dams by examining the impact on water and aquatic environments. The three central objectives of the SAGE in order to attain a positive status of the water bodies being; the reduction of polluting flows from agriculture, the development of the territory and the preservation of the fauna and the flora of aquatic environments. As such, the SAGE has advocated:
– Establishment of multi-year river restoration and maintenance programs
– The clearing of watercourses
– The restoration of the Sélune migratory axis at the end of the concession of the hydroelectric dams of Vezins and Roche-Qui-Boit (2013).
Among the 4 other objectives enacted to reconcile human activities, the SAGE has also included a specific objective on the fate of the dams, as defined in the following recommendations:
– management of the dams during the concession phase so that dam operations takes into account other users, in particular with regard to water quality, the downstream flow, tides and the provision of a reserve for drinking water, compensating for the evaporation of reservoirs,
– removal of the dams after the concession, by defining and implementing precautionary measures for the emptying and dismantling of the dams and by providing for corrective measures during emptying and de-construction operations.
– Law on water and aquatic environments (Article L 214-17 of the Environment Code) providing the legal framework for the reopening of the valley. A project considered all the more relevant as the degradation of water (eutrophication storage of hazardous substances) has been amplified by the dams.
– On July the 26th, 2006, the prefect of La Manche issued a decree ordering EDF to equip its dams for the movement of migratory fish, requiring it within 6 months to provide a technical report specifying the nature and modalities of the works to be installed or, failing that, any technical justification on the impossibility of carrying them out.
– January the 25th, 2007: EDF provides a report that concludes, as in previous studies, the impossibility of assuring the practicability of running the dam franchises. The reasons for this impossibility lie in the height of the Vézins dam (36m), the extent of its reservoir, which generates delays and prohibitive predation losses during upstream and downstream migration, the technical impossibility of equipping the dams for the downstream migration, whose type of turbines is responsible for 46 to 57% cumulative smolt mortality on both structures.
– End of concession of the dams: approval of the SAGE Sélune by the State and so dam removal.
2009 : The ministerial decision
Given this opinion, the issue of migratory fish on the Sélune (river classified under Article L.432-6 of the Environment Code, particularly for Atlantic Salmon and European eel) and the lack of technical possibilities for the rearrangement of the dams, and in the light of the conclusions of a working group led by the Prefect, the State decides, in accordance with the commitment made in the framework of the Grenelle of the environment, do not renew the administrative titles of the dams of Vezins and Roche-Qui-Boit.
This decision was announced on November the 13th, 2009 in Lisieux by Mrs. Chantal JOUANNO, Secretary of State for Ecology, during the launch for the national action plan for ecological river continuity restoration.
The operation to remove dams and re-naturalize the Sélune was then included in the “commitment agreement for sustainable hydropower and consistent with the restoration of aquatic environments following the Grenelle de l’Environnement”, signed on June 23 2010 between the State and 17 partners (including associations of elected representatives, representative associations of hydropower, major hydroelectric producers and environmental protection associations).
– Inscription of the Sélune in the Priority Action Zone for the restoration of migratory transparency in the French Eel Management Plan adopted by the European Commission in Brussels in application of the European Regulation on Eel n ° 1100/2007.
– The Administrative Appeal Court of Nantes, in a judgment dated October the 19th, 2010, put the operator on notice (the State now for Vezins) to restore the free movement of migratory fish by the end of 2013 following the litigation initiated following the decree of formal notice to EDF to equip its works for the circulation of the migrating fish taken on July the 26th, 2006 by the prefect of Manche.
2012 : The ministerial decision concretized by two Orders of the Manche Prefect on July 3, 2012
– Order decreeing the cessation of the operation of the concession and authorized of Vezins and Roche-Boit on the Sélune dams,
– Order concerning the public safety management of the Vezins dams on the Sélune by EDF SA until the free flow of the Sélune waters is restored.
2014 : Public inquiry in favor but retreat of Ségolène Royal Ecological Ministry
– November 2014: The commission of inquiry gave a favorable opinion on the dismantling of the dams. The participation was strong: 882 letters received, 2,826 mails, 857 entries in the city halls registers, a total of 4,565 notices filed.
– December the 4th, 2014 Mrs. Ségolène Royal, then Minister of Ecology, visiting the department and following the meeting with local actors in at la Mazure announces against all odds the stop of the process of removing the dams and asks for new expertise.
2017 : The Sélune soon free again !
– March 2017: Drainage and sediment management work are conducted on the reservoir of Vezins to allow the safety review of the structure.
– The Minister of the Transition Ecological and Solidarity, Nicolas Hulot, announced on November the 14th, 2017 his decision to relaunch the process of removed the dams of Vezins and La-Roche-qui-Boit.
2019 : Start of works
– April 2019: The final emptying of the Vezins reservoir start of the dismantling of the powerplant house.
– 12th of June 2019 : In a historic moment for Europe’s rivers, the first, irreparable breach was made today in the 36 metre high Vezins Dam – kick-starting the biggest dam removal in Europe so far.
– 24-26 September 2019 : European Rivers Network, the French Agency for Biodiversity, the National Federation for Fishing in France and Dam Removal Europe, and the National Institute of Agronomic Research (INRA), the Water Agency Seine-Normandie and the NGO Aliance “Friends of the Sélune” organise in Rennes and Avranches an international conference on dam removal and the restoration of the Selune valley. page du colloque
– November 2019 : 60 % of the 36 m high dam Vezins removed.
2020 : End of work on Vezins and start of work on La Roche qui Boit
Since March, and in view of the health crisis linked to Covid 19, the Vezins works carried out by the DDTM 50 has been at a standstill. 90% of the dam has been removed, only the central pier and the foundations remain. With some delay, the works will resume until September so that finally the Sélune river can find its bed again.
June: On the La Roche-qui-boit dam downstream, EDF, the project manager for the site, will launch the sediment management work in June 2020. The final emptying of the reservoir is scheduled for April 2021 and the deconstruction of the dam at the end of 2021-early 2022.
BROCHURES AND OTHER PUBLICATIONS
- “Quand les rivières reprennent leur cours – Notes sur l’effacement de barrages et de seuils, sur la Sélune et ailleurs”. – OFB, Marchs 2021, in french only, 76 pages
- Dam removal: The Sélune River free to run – 24 to 26 september 2019, Les Rencontres, OFB, n°70, déc.2019, english, 6 pages
- Let’s adopt the Selune Valley, les Amis de la Sélune (english)
- NASF Sélune brochure (english)
- Convention hydroélectricité durable et restauration des milieux aquatiques , in french only
- Enlever les vieux barrages inutiles sur la Loire et les rivières de France, un progrès pour la restauration écologique des fleuves, WWF 2008, in french only
- Interview 24-26 september 2019 ,Flussreporter
- Interview de Normandie Grands Migrateurs, INRA, du SAGE de la Sélune et de l’association des Amis du Barrage, BBC, avril2018, 27min
- ERNs Reportage, 12 Minutes, May 2021, Sélune dam removal(s) : What is the status (french and english)
- TV report (4 th November 2019), France 3 (french)
- TV report (July 2019), Al Jazzeera (english)
- Vidéo sur l’effacement des barrages de la Sélune, AFB, AESN, EDF, 2015
- Video removal Sélune dams, AFB, AESN, EDF (english subtitle)
- International conference on dam removal :” Selune Valley revival“, september 2019
PRESS RELEASE / ARTICLES
- Pressrelease 21.11.2017 – ERN / WWF international
- Communiqué de presse 16.11.2017 – Amis de la Sélune
- Communiqué de presse 14.11.2017 – Ministère de la Transition Ecologique et Solidaire
- Communiqué de presse 26.06.2015 – Amis de la Sélune
- Communiqué de presse 05.12.2014 – Amis de la Sélune
- Communiqué de presse 18.12.2012 – Amis de la Sélune
- Communiqué de presse 04.07.2012 – Amis de la Sélune
- Information presse 03.07.2012 – Ministère de l’Ecologie
- Communiqué de presse 16.02.2102 – FNPF
- Communiqué de presse 11.2009 – ONGs
- Sélune: Größter Staudammabbruch in EuropaAtlantischer Lachs, Aal und Alse bekommen ihren Fluss zurück, online magazine Flussreporter, novembre 2019.
- Barrages de la Sélune, la coupe est pleine : Ségolène Royal remet en cause le projet , Loire mail 199 -juin 2016 SOS Loire Vivante – ERN France
- 25 juin 2015 : Rivernews France : focus Sélune et 5ème anniversaire de la Convention pour une Hydroélectricité Durable
Protection and classification measures of Sélune
Watercourses classified in list 1 and 2 under Article L. 214-17 of the Environment Code
– list 1: The Sélune from the confluence with the Airon (in Saint Hilaire du Harcouet) to the sea (estuary included)
– list 1: The Sélune of the confluence with the Moulin Richard (in Barenton) at the confluence with the Airon (in Saint Hilaire du Harcouet
– list 2: The Selune, from the point defined by the coordinates L. 93: X: 408392, Y: 6840449 at the downstream limit of the mass of water: [FRHR. 351] the Selune from the foot of the La Roche Qui Boit dam to the mouth.
Watercourses classified under Article L. 432-6 of the Environment Code
– Sélune, downstream from its confluence with La Gueuche (communes of Lapenty and Milly) for Atlantic salmon, sea trout, brown trout, European eel, pike, sea lamprey, river lamprey. It imposes in fact a compliance of existing dams;
– the Oir, downstream of the RD 47 bridge from Avranches to Isigny-le-Buat for Atlantic salmon, sea trout, brown trout and European eel;
– Beuvron throughout the Manche departement for Atlantic salmon, sea trout, brown trout and European eel.
Rivers reserved under the law of October 16, 1919
– Sélune downstream of the barrage of La Roche-Boit;
– The Oir downstream from its confluence with the ruisseau de la Vallée-aux-Berges (communes of Mancellière and Isigny-le-Buat);
– the Beuvron on all its course;
Migratory axes with major interest of the SDAGE
– Sélune downstream of the confluence with the brook of Bahan;
– Oir downstream of the confluence with Roche;
– the Beuvron (in the Channel).
EEL Management Plan (EMP) pursuant to the Regulation “eel” 1100/2007– priority action zone 2 (ZAP2): the Selune and its tributaries, downstream of the 3rd hydroelectric structure from the sea
– 10 obstacles on the EMP: 4 on the Sélune and 6 on the Beuvron